Top Picks
Warehouse Women's Mid Rise Denim Darted Barrel Leg Jeans in Washed Black
NADIA’S PICK MISSPAPWarehouse Women's Mid Rise Denim Darted Barrel Leg Jeans in Washed Black
£44.90 £22.00 MISSPAP
Dorothy Perkins Black Floral Lace Trim Pleat Bodice Puff Sleeve Midi Dress
ESME’S PICK DOROTHY PERKINSDorothy Perkins Black Floral Lace Trim Pleat Bodice Puff Sleeve Midi Dress
£39.00 £23.40 DOROTHY PERKINS
1 Pair Black Pure Matt 100 Tights Ladies Small
HANNAH’S PICK SOCK SHOP1 Pair Black Pure Matt 100 Tights Ladies Small
£34.99 SOCK SHOP
1 Pair Black Pure Matt 100 Tights Ladies Extra Large
SIOBHAN’S PICK SOCK SHOP1 Pair Black Pure Matt 100 Tights Ladies Extra Large
£34.99 SOCK SHOP
Vionic Alameda Mary Janes In Black
TAMSIN’S PICK DOROTHY PERKINSVionic Alameda Mary Janes In Black
£125.00 DOROTHY PERKINS
How we pick

Every collection on What She Wears starts with a pile of products and ends with a short list chosen by real women. For black comfort mary janes, that was Nadia, Esme, Hannah, Siobhan and Tamsin. They looked at shape, fabric, reviews where there were any and, honestly, whether it made them want to wear it this weekend. Things that look great on a model and terrible on a hanger tend to get cut. The full list underneath is everything that matched, from lots of different shops, so you can still have a proper browse.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money

Under £5011 pieces
1 Pair Black Pure Matt 100 Tights Ladies Large
SOCK SHOP

1 Pair Black Pure Matt 100 Tights Ladies Large

£34.99 SOCK SHOP
Ajvani Flat Heel Comfort Mary Janes In Black
DOROTHY PERKINS

Ajvani Flat Heel Comfort Mary Janes In Black

£23.99 DOROTHY PERKINS
1 Pair Black Pure Matt 100 Tights Ladies Medium
SOCK SHOP

1 Pair Black Pure Matt 100 Tights Ladies Medium

£34.99 SOCK SHOP
1 Pair Black Pure Matt 100 Tights Ladies Small
SOCK SHOP

1 Pair Black Pure Matt 100 Tights Ladies Small

£34.99 SOCK SHOP
1 Pair Black Pure Matt 100 Tights Ladies Extra Large
SOCK SHOP

1 Pair Black Pure Matt 100 Tights Ladies Extra Large

£34.99 SOCK SHOP
−50%Boohoo Square Toe Triple Strap Mary Jane Shoes In Black
DOROTHY PERKINS

Boohoo Square Toe Triple Strap Mary Jane Shoes In Black

£24.00 £12.00 DOROTHY PERKINS
−51%Warehouse Women's Mid Rise Denim Darted Barrel Leg Jeans in Washed Black
MISSPAP

Warehouse Women's Mid Rise Denim Darted Barrel Leg Jeans in Washed Black

£44.90 £22.00 MISSPAP
−51%Warehouse Mid Rise Denim Darted Barrel Leg Jeans In Washed Black
DOROTHY PERKINS

Warehouse Mid Rise Denim Darted Barrel Leg Jeans In Washed Black

£44.90 £22.00 DOROTHY PERKINS
−40%Dorothy Perkins Black Floral Lace Trim Pleat Bodice Puff Sleeve Midi Dress
DOROTHY PERKINS

Dorothy Perkins Black Floral Lace Trim Pleat Bodice Puff Sleeve Midi Dress

£39.00 £23.40 DOROTHY PERKINS
OFFICE Womens Haisley Platform Mary Jane Heels Black Patent
OFFICE SHOES

OFFICE Womens Haisley Platform Mary Jane Heels Black Patent

£52.99 OFFICE SHOES
−20%Vionic Uptown Mj Mary Janes In Black
DOROTHY PERKINS

Vionic Uptown Mj Mary Janes In Black

£119.99 £95.99 DOROTHY PERKINS
Worth the splurge7 pieces
Flabelus Womens Mary Janes Pink Velvet
OFFICE SHOES

Flabelus Womens Mary Janes Pink Velvet

£118.00 OFFICE SHOES
Birkenstock Womens Mantova Mary Janes Black High Shine
OFFICE SHOES

Birkenstock Womens Mantova Mary Janes Black High Shine

£200.00 OFFICE SHOES
Flabelus Womens Mary Janes Linen Beige Yellow Natural
OFFICE SHOES

Flabelus Womens Mary Janes Linen Beige Yellow Natural

£118.00 OFFICE SHOES
Birkenstock Womens Santa Clarita Mary Janes Sandcastle Nubuck Natural
OFFICE SHOES

Birkenstock Womens Santa Clarita Mary Janes Sandcastle Nubuck Natural

£125.00 OFFICE SHOES
Birkenstock Mantova Mary Janes
ANTHROPOLOGIE

Birkenstock Mantova Mary Janes

£140.00 ANTHROPOLOGIE
Vionic Alameda Mary Janes In Black
DOROTHY PERKINS

Vionic Alameda Mary Janes In Black

£125.00 DOROTHY PERKINS
−19%UGG Womens Goldenstar Mary Janes Black
OFFICE SHOES

UGG Womens Goldenstar Mary Janes Black

£129.63 £105.00 OFFICE SHOES

More like this

See all in Black Shoes →
Finding the Best Black Slip On ShoesBlack ShoesFinding the Best Black Slip On ShoesBlack Studded Shoes That Go With EverythingBlack ShoesBlack Studded Shoes That Go With EverythingBlack Faux Leather Shoes That Go With EverythingBlack ShoesBlack Faux Leather Shoes That Go With EverythingThe Only Black Block Heel Mary Janes You Need to SeeBlack ShoesThe Only Black Block Heel Mary Janes You Need to SeeShop Our Favourite Black Platform EspadrillesEspadrillesShop Our Favourite Black Platform EspadrillesBlack Leather Espadrilles: Picks We Stand ByEspadrillesBlack Leather Espadrilles: Picks We Stand By