A hat's job changes with what you're asking of it. Some are there to keep rain off and your ears warm when the wind's coming straight off the sea and no amount of hood will do. Some are there to cover second day hair and let you leave the house ten minutes faster. Some are purely about cutting glare on a bright morning so you're not squinting through the school run or a long drive. Different jobs, but the same test applies to all of them: does it actually stay on, and do you reach for it without thinking.
Colour wise, I'd always steer you towards the ones that behave like neutrals even when they're not strictly neutral. Camel, navy, a proper grey, black that hasn't gone slightly green with age, these sit under or over almost anything without an argument. A soft rust or a deep bottle green earns its place too, because they lift a plain coat without looking like you tried too hard. Where people come unstuck is buying the hat in the exact shade of one specific coat, then wondering why it does nothing for anything else they own. Pair a beanie with a wool coat and jeans and it looks like you dressed on purpose. A cap sits happily on top of a plain jumper and trainers and does most of its work there, not over anything fussy. A visor wants simplicity around it, a vest top, a linen shirt, nothing competing for attention. Autumn through to early spring is beanie and cap weather here, proper cold needs something with actual substance to it, not a thin layer that looks the part for a photograph and nothing else. Visors are fair weather only, and look faintly ridiculous the moment it rains, which it will.
The difference between a hat worth keeping and one that's bin material inside a year is almost always in the detail nobody photographs. A beanie should have a decent weight of yarn, enough that it holds its shape rather than slumping by midday, and a brim that doesn't unravel after one wash. A cap wants a stitched peak that doesn't go soft and floppy, proper eyelets, and a strap or closure that won't snap the first time you adjust it in a hurry. Cheap hardware on any of them, a flimsy clasp, a zip that catches, tells you everything about how the rest was made.
I'd start with navy. It goes with almost everything I already own, and I've never once regretted buying it.
BeaniesWool Oversized Beanies That Finish Any Look
CapsWool Oversized Caps That Make Lovely Gifts
Wool Oversized Hats: What We’d Buy Now
BeaniesCosy Wool Pom Pom Beanies We Love
Our Kind of Wool Pom Pom Hats
BeaniesOur Top Wool Ribbed Beanies Right Now
CapsWool Ribbed Caps We’re Adding to Basket
Wool Ribbed Hats We’d Happily Wear on Repeat
Wool Sun Hats That Have Caught Our EyeAlso worth a lookCapsThe first thing I check on a cap is the underside of the brim, right where it meets the crown.See the collections →
VisorsHandpicked Wool Visors We Keep Coming Back To
BeaniesWool Wide Brim Beanies for Colder Days
CapsWool Wide Brim Caps: Our Honest Shortlist
Wool Wide Brim Hats: The Edit
BeaniesWool Chunky Beanies: Picks We Stand By
Our Kind of Wool Chunky Berets
CapsThe Best Looking Wool Chunky Caps Out There
Our Go To Wool Chunky Hats
CapsThe Edit: Wool Embroidered Baseball CapsAlso worth a lookBeaniesA beanie is the one hat I never have to talk myself into, because it doesn't ask anything…See the collections →
BeaniesOur Kind of Wool Embroidered Beanies
Cosy Wool Embroidered Berets We Love
CapsWool Embroidered Caps: Picks We Stand By
Wool Embroidered Hats to See You Through Winter
VisorsWool Embroidered Visors That Pull an Outfit Together
CapsWool Fisherman Caps That Have Caught Our Eye
BeaniesWool Fluffy Beanies Picked by Us
Our Shortlist of Wool Bucket Hats
Wool Fluffy Hats That Have Caught Our EyeAlso worth a lookVisorsVisors have always had a slightly ridiculous reputation, somewhere between a tennis court in 1997 and a golf…See the collections →
BeaniesWool Cable Knit Beanies We’d Recommend to a Friend
BeaniesThe Wool Fold Over Beanies Every Wardrobe Needs
Wool Cable Knit Hats to See You Through Winter
Wool Fold Over Hats for Colder Days
CapsThe Best Wool Caps to Shop Now
Finishing Touch Wool Hats We Love
BeaniesOur Pick of the Best Winter Beanies
Cosy Winter Berets We Love
