Top Picks
Alohas Womens Katia Ballet Flats Black Leather, 3.5
MAGGIE’S PICK OFFICE SHOESAlohas Womens Katia Ballet Flats Black Leather, 3.5
£170.00 OFFICE SHOES
Naturalizer Charlotte Ballet Flats In Black
LAUREN’S PICK DOROTHY PERKINSNaturalizer Charlotte Ballet Flats In Black
£109.99 £87.99 DOROTHY PERKINS
Linzi Hush Black Faux Leather Mary Jane Style Flats
DANI’S PICK DOROTHY PERKINSLinzi Hush Black Faux Leather Mary Jane Style Flats
£32.99 DOROTHY PERKINS
Lauren Ralph Lauren BARNSBURY-FLATS-DRIVER women's Loafers / Casual Shoes in Black
ELLIE’S PICK SPARTOOLauren Ralph Lauren BARNSBURY-FLATS-DRIVER women's Loafers / Casual Shoes in Black
£147.00 £132.30 SPARTOO
Black Iris crochet ballerina flats
ROSIE’S PICK THE DOUBLE FBlack Iris crochet ballerina flats
£330.00 £247.50 THE DOUBLE F
How we pick

These picks came from Maggie, Lauren, Dani, Ellie and Rosie, who each chose the one they'd happily wear themselves. That's the whole test really. Would we buy it, would we wear it more than once, and does it look like the photo once it arrives? We skip anything that looks cheap up close, cap how many pieces come from any one shop, and keep the list fresh as stock changes. We earn a small commission if you buy through our links, it never costs you more, and it never decides what gets picked.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money

Under £504 pieces
Linzi Hush Black Faux Leather Mary Jane Style Flats
DOROTHY PERKINS

Linzi Hush Black Faux Leather Mary Jane Style Flats

£32.99 DOROTHY PERKINS
Black Faux Leather Loafers
PRETTYLITTLETHING

Black Faux Leather Loafers

£16.50 PRETTYLITTLETHING
Womens Wide Fit Hotter Leap Shoes, Brown / 5 / 3E
WIDE FIT SHOES

Womens Wide Fit Hotter Leap Shoes, Brown / 5 / 3E

£45.99 WIDE FIT SHOES
−53%Dorothy Perkins Lennie Tassel Loafers In Black
DOROTHY PERKINS

Dorothy Perkins Lennie Tassel Loafers In Black

£31.91 £15.00 DOROTHY PERKINS
£50 to £1005 pieces
Steve Madden 'nafisa Loafer Black' Leather Flats
DOROTHY PERKINS

Steve Madden 'nafisa Loafer Black' Leather Flats

£89.00 DOROTHY PERKINS
PUMA Speedcat Suede Ballet Flats
ANTHROPOLOGIE

PUMA Speedcat Suede Ballet Flats

£70.00 ANTHROPOLOGIE
−22%Carvela 'sky Tassel' Patent Flats In Black
DOROTHY PERKINS

Carvela 'sky Tassel' Patent Flats In Black

£88.46 £69.00 DOROTHY PERKINS
−32%Tony Bianco Womens Hawaii Strap Ballet Pumps Black Nappa
OFFICE SHOES

Tony Bianco Womens Hawaii Strap Ballet Pumps Black Nappa

£110.29 £75.00 OFFICE SHOES
−20%Naturalizer Charlotte Ballet Flats In Black
DOROTHY PERKINS

Naturalizer Charlotte Ballet Flats In Black

£109.99 £87.99 DOROTHY PERKINS
Worth the splurge16 pieces
Steve Madden 'lydia Black' Leather Flats
DOROTHY PERKINS

Steve Madden 'lydia Black' Leather Flats

£120.00 DOROTHY PERKINS
STEVE MADDEN Women's 'Langsten Black' Leather Flats in Black
MISSPAP

STEVE MADDEN Women's 'Langsten Black' Leather Flats in Black

£160.00 MISSPAP
STEVE MADDEN Women's 'Alba Black' Leather Flats in Black
MISSPAP

STEVE MADDEN Women's 'Alba Black' Leather Flats in Black

£220.00 MISSPAP
Vagabond Womens Aleya Ballet Pumps Cream Natural
OFFICE SHOES

Vagabond Womens Aleya Ballet Pumps Cream Natural

£120.00 OFFICE SHOES
STEVE MADDEN Women's 'Fern Black Leather' Leather Flats
MISSPAP

STEVE MADDEN Women's 'Fern Black Leather' Leather Flats

£130.00 MISSPAP
STEVE MADDEN Women's 'Lydia Black' Leather Flats in Black
MISSPAP

STEVE MADDEN Women's 'Lydia Black' Leather Flats in Black

£120.00 MISSPAP
Alohas Womens Sway Flats Black
OFFICE SHOES

Alohas Womens Sway Flats Black

£145.00 OFFICE SHOES
STEVE MADDEN Women's 'Roger Black' Leather Flats in Black
MISSPAP

STEVE MADDEN Women's 'Roger Black' Leather Flats in Black

£160.00 MISSPAP
Alohas Womens Katia Ballet Flats Black Leather, 3.5
OFFICE SHOES

Alohas Womens Katia Ballet Flats Black Leather, 3.5

£170.00 OFFICE SHOES
Vagabond Womens Aleya Ballet Flats Black Leather
OFFICE SHOES

Vagabond Womens Aleya Ballet Flats Black Leather

£120.00 OFFICE SHOES
Lauren Ralph Lauren JAYNA-FLATS-CASUAL women's Shoes (Pumps / Ballerinas) in Black
SPARTOO

Lauren Ralph Lauren JAYNA-FLATS-CASUAL women's Shoes (Pumps / Ballerinas) in Black

£123.00 SPARTOO
STEVE MADDEN Women's 'Lando Black' Leather Flats in Black
MISSPAP

STEVE MADDEN Women's 'Lando Black' Leather Flats in Black

£120.00 MISSPAP
Black ballet flats with small studs
THE DOUBLE F

Black ballet flats with small studs

£190.00 THE DOUBLE F
−10%Lauren Ralph Lauren BARNSBURY-FLATS-DRIVER women's Loafers / Casual Shoes in Black
SPARTOO

Lauren Ralph Lauren BARNSBURY-FLATS-DRIVER women's Loafers / Casual Shoes in Black

£147.00 £132.30 SPARTOO
−29%Alohas Womens Bumi Ballet Flats Black Leather, 3.5
OFFICE SHOES

Alohas Womens Bumi Ballet Flats Black Leather, 3.5

£190.14 £135.00 OFFICE SHOES
−25%Black Iris crochet ballerina flats
THE DOUBLE F

Black Iris crochet ballerina flats

£330.00 £247.50 THE DOUBLE F

More like this

See all in Flats →
Gold Leather Ballet Flats: Our Honest ShortlistBallet FlatsGold Leather Ballet Flats: Our Honest ShortlistThe Best Black Raffia Flats to Shop NowFlatsThe Best Black Raffia Flats to Shop NowLace Up Ballet Flats Worth Putting Your Best Foot Forward InBallet FlatsLace Up Ballet Flats Worth Putting Your Best Foot Forward InWhite Strappy Flats: Our Top PicksFlatsWhite Strappy Flats: Our Top PicksRunning Flats Worth a Closer LookFlatsRunning Flats Worth a Closer LookCut Out Flats You’ll Actually Want to Walk InFlatsCut Out Flats You’ll Actually Want to Walk In