Top Picks
Black High Heels Dress Shoes Pointed Toe Patent Leather Stilettos Pumps
HANNAH’S PICK MILANOOBlack High Heels Dress Shoes Pointed Toe Patent Leather Stilettos Pumps
£61.20 £42.84 MILANOO
Vagabond Womens Aleya Ballet Pumps Cream Natural
CHLOE’S PICK OFFICE SHOESVagabond Womens Aleya Ballet Pumps Cream Natural
£120.00 OFFICE SHOES
Puma Womens Ballet Nova Pumps Powder Pink Black, 3.5
DANI’S PICK OFFICE SHOESPuma Womens Ballet Nova Pumps Powder Pink Black, 3.5
£69.99 OFFICE SHOES
BLOCH Ladies Lyra Ballet Pumps, Black Pink Leather
ELLIE’S PICK BLOCH DANCEBLOCH Ladies Lyra Ballet Pumps, Black Pink Leather
£85.00 BLOCH DANCE
Castaner Gagan women's Shoes (Pumps / Ballerinas) in Black
ZARA’S PICK SPARTOOCastaner Gagan women's Shoes (Pumps / Ballerinas) in Black
£143.00 £121.55 SPARTOO
How we pick

Every collection on What She Wears starts with a pile of products and ends with a short list chosen by real women. For black leather pumps, that was Hannah, Chloe, Dani, Ellie and Zara. They looked at shape, fabric, reviews where there were any and, honestly, whether it made them want to wear it this weekend. Things that look great on a model and terrible on a hanger tend to get cut. The full list underneath is everything that matched, from lots of different shops, so you can still have a proper browse.

We may earn a small commission if you buy through links on this page. It costs you nothing extra and helps keep the site running. How we make money

Under £507 pieces
Gothic Lolita Shoes Platform Black Bows PU Leather Flat Lolita Pumps
MILANOO

Gothic Lolita Shoes Platform Black Bows PU Leather Flat Lolita Pumps

£32.71 MILANOO
−15%ROCOCO Style Lolita Footwear Black Bows Ruffles Pearls Round Toe PU Leather Lolita Pumps
MILANOO

ROCOCO Style Lolita Footwear Black Bows Ruffles Pearls Round Toe PU Leather Lolita Pumps

£34.82 £29.60 MILANOO
−20%Dorothy Perkins Faith: Alice Mesh Detail Mary-Jane Ballet Pumps In Black
DOROTHY PERKINS

Dorothy Perkins Faith: Alice Mesh Detail Mary-Jane Ballet Pumps In Black

£39.00 £31.20 DOROTHY PERKINS
−10%Dorothy Perkins Barrie Faux Leather Low Heel Ballet Pumps In Black
DOROTHY PERKINS

Dorothy Perkins Barrie Faux Leather Low Heel Ballet Pumps In Black

£39.00 £35.10 DOROTHY PERKINS
−51%Dune London 'handle' Leather Ballet Pumps In Black
DOROTHY PERKINS

Dune London 'handle' Leather Ballet Pumps In Black

£79.59 £39.00 DOROTHY PERKINS
−30%Black High Heels Pointed Toe Patchwork PU Leather Stiletto Heel Pumps
MILANOO

Black High Heels Pointed Toe Patchwork PU Leather Stiletto Heel Pumps

£57.86 £40.50 MILANOO
−30%Black High Heels Dress Shoes Pointed Toe Patent Leather Stilettos Pumps
MILANOO

Black High Heels Dress Shoes Pointed Toe Patent Leather Stilettos Pumps

£61.20 £42.84 MILANOO
£50 to £10014 pieces
Dune London 'hetta' Leather Ballet Pumps In Black
DOROTHY PERKINS

Dune London 'hetta' Leather Ballet Pumps In Black

£79.00 DOROTHY PERKINS
Casual Attitude HOLMA women's Shoes (Pumps / Ballerinas) in Black
SPARTOO

Casual Attitude HOLMA women's Shoes (Pumps / Ballerinas) in Black

£64.00 SPARTOO
Puma Womens Speedcat Ballet Pumps Matte Bronze Black Multi
OFFICE SHOES

Puma Womens Speedcat Ballet Pumps Matte Bronze Black Multi

£74.99 OFFICE SHOES
Gothic Lolita Footwear Black PU Leather Wedge Heel Lolita Pumps
MILANOO

Gothic Lolita Footwear Black PU Leather Wedge Heel Lolita Pumps

£84.91 MILANOO
BLOCH Ladies Lyra Ballet Pumps, Black Mint Leather
BLOCH DANCE

BLOCH Ladies Lyra Ballet Pumps, Black Mint Leather

£85.00 BLOCH DANCE
BLOCH Ladies Lyra Ballet Pumps, Black Pink Leather
BLOCH DANCE

BLOCH Ladies Lyra Ballet Pumps, Black Pink Leather

£85.00 BLOCH DANCE
Puma Womens Ballet Nova Pumps Matte Bronze Black Multi, 3.5
OFFICE SHOES

Puma Womens Ballet Nova Pumps Matte Bronze Black Multi, 3.5

£69.99 OFFICE SHOES
Puma Womens Ballet Nova Pumps Powder Pink Black, 3.5
OFFICE SHOES

Puma Womens Ballet Nova Pumps Powder Pink Black, 3.5

£69.99 OFFICE SHOES
Dune London 'honora' Leather Ballet Pumps In Black
DOROTHY PERKINS

Dune London 'honora' Leather Ballet Pumps In Black

£89.00 DOROTHY PERKINS
Sweet Lolita Footwear Black Chains Round Toe PU Leather Lolita Pumps
MILANOO

Sweet Lolita Footwear Black Chains Round Toe PU Leather Lolita Pumps

£61.54 MILANOO
Gabor 'ruffle' Casual Shoes In Jet Black
DOROTHY PERKINS

Gabor 'ruffle' Casual Shoes In Jet Black

£85.00 DOROTHY PERKINS
−32%Clarks FRECKLE ICE women's Shoes (Pumps / Ballerinas) in Black
SPARTOO

Clarks FRECKLE ICE women's Shoes (Pumps / Ballerinas) in Black

£86.00 £58.48 SPARTOO
−30%Unisa ACOR women's Shoes (Pumps / Ballerinas) in Black
SPARTOO

Unisa ACOR women's Shoes (Pumps / Ballerinas) in Black

£87.00 £60.90 SPARTOO
−25%Clarks FAWNA LILY women's Shoes (Pumps / Ballerinas) in Black
SPARTOO

Clarks FAWNA LILY women's Shoes (Pumps / Ballerinas) in Black

£96.00 £72.00 SPARTOO
Worth the splurge4 pieces
Alohas Womens Rosalind Ballet Pumps Black, 3.5
OFFICE SHOES

Alohas Womens Rosalind Ballet Pumps Black, 3.5

£150.00 OFFICE SHOES
El Naturalista ARENISCA women's Shoes (Pumps / Ballerinas) in Black
SPARTOO

El Naturalista ARENISCA women's Shoes (Pumps / Ballerinas) in Black

£104.00 SPARTOO
Vagabond Womens Aleya Ballet Pumps Cream Natural
OFFICE SHOES

Vagabond Womens Aleya Ballet Pumps Cream Natural

£120.00 OFFICE SHOES
−15%Castaner Gagan women's Shoes (Pumps / Ballerinas) in Black
SPARTOO

Castaner Gagan women's Shoes (Pumps / Ballerinas) in Black

£143.00 £121.55 SPARTOO

More like this

See all in Pumps →
Black Flat Ballet Pumps Edited Down to the BestBallet PumpsBlack Flat Ballet Pumps Edited Down to the BestThe Buckle Pumps ShortlistPumpsThe Buckle Pumps ShortlistThe Best Black Heeled Pumps to Shop NowPumpsThe Best Black Heeled Pumps to Shop NowWhite Slip On Pumps You’ll Actually Want to Walk InPumpsWhite Slip On Pumps You’ll Actually Want to Walk InBlack Comfort Pumps Edited Down to the BestPumpsBlack Comfort Pumps Edited Down to the BestBrown Leather Ballet Pumps That Go With EverythingBallet PumpsBrown Leather Ballet Pumps That Go With Everything