I used to think one black belt did the job of all of them, so for years I had a single thin plastic one that came free with a dress and lived in a drawer getting cracked at the buckle. Then I bought a proper leather one by accident, really, I grabbed it to hold up a pair of jeans in a changing room and ended up wearing it every day for two years. Turns out the cheap one wasn’t doing nothing. It was doing the job badly.
A good black belt starts with the leather, or a faux that’s been made to behave like leather, not shine like a bin bag. Pick it up and bend it. It should curve, not crease into a hard line, and the edge should be finished, not left raw and fraying after a few wears. The buckle matters more than people think. A flimsy one will warp or go loose at the pin within months, so give it a proper press with your thumb, you want resistance, not give. Stitching should sit close to the edge and be even all the way round. If you’re only buying one, go for a medium width, about an inch and a half, in a matt finish, because that’s the one that will sit happily through a belt loop on jeans and still look right cinching in a dress. And do check where it sits on you, not just the length, because a belt that’s correctly sized at the waist but cut too wide will ride up on anyone shortish through the body and look like it’s strangling a cardigan.
Jeans, trench coats, a plain shirt dress, all easy. It earns its keep on anything with waist loops that gape slightly without one, and on a shapeless jumper dress it’s the difference between looking dressed and looking like you’re still in your pyjamas. It fights with anything that already has a defined waist, like a wrap dress or a fitted blazer, where adding a belt just creates a second waistline and confuses the eye. It also fights with bulky knitwear, the buckle gets lost and the leather bunches.
It won’t rescue a dress that’s cut badly through the middle, and it won’t make narrow loops fit a wide belt, that’s a different belt, not a different problem. Buy the better one. It outlasts three cheap ones and never once embarrasses you at the buckle.
Leather BeltsOur Shortlist of Black Woven Leather Belts
Black Woven Statement Belts: Our Honest Shortlist
Black Woven Statement Waist Belts That Pull an Outfit Together
Black Woven Waist Belts That Tick Every Box
Leather BeltsBlack Woven Waist Leather Belts Worth Treating Yourself To
Wide BeltsBlack Woven Wide Belts That Pull an Outfit Together
Wide BeltsThe Edit: Black Woven Wide Waist Belts
Wide BeltsBlack Wide Waist Belts That Earn Their Place
Black Woven Belts That Finish Any LookAlso worth a lookLeather BeltsI spent years treating belts as an afterthought, something you grab off the back of the door because your jeans are loose that day.See the collections →
Wide BeltsBlack Wide Belts We’ve Been Saving
Wide BeltsBlack Wide Leather Belts: Our Honest Shortlist
Where to Find the Best Black Waist Belts
Leather BeltsBlack Waist Leather Belts That Make Lovely Gifts
A Closer Look at the Best Black Western Belts
Black Underwired Suspender Belts That Pull an Outfit Together
A Closer Look at the Best Black Suspender Belts
Finishing Touch Black Studded Belts We Love
Leather BeltsBlack Studded Leather Belts: Our Top PicksAlso worth a lookWide BeltsI didn't understand wide belts until I wore one over a plain dress for a whole day at…See the collections →
Black Suede Belts We Love Right Now
The Black Statement Belts Every Wardrobe Needs
Leather BeltsOur Edit of the Best Black Statement Leather Belts
Our Shortlist of Black Statement Waist Belts
Leather BeltsStandout Black Silver Buckle Leather Belts to Shop
Black Silver Buckle Waist Belts That Make Lovely Gifts
Finishing Touch Black Skinny Belts We Love
Leather BeltsBlack Skinny Leather Belts We Rate
Black Skinny Waist Belts Worth Treating Yourself ToAlso worth a lookBeltsFor years I thought a belt was just the thing holding your trousers up, so I bought one,…See the collections →
Black Silver Buckle Belts: The Edit
Shop the Edit: Black Sheer Suspender Belts
Our Favourite Black Satin Suspender Belts
Our Favourite Black Reversible Belts
Leather BeltsOur Favourite Black Reversible Leather Belts
Our Shortlist of Black Plus Size Belts
Our Shortlist of Black Metal Belts
Leather BeltsBlack Metal Leather Belts That Finish Any Look
