Travel bags have a reputation for being the thing you buy in a panic three days before a trip and regret within a week of actually using it. Mine mostly holds up. A proper one earns its spot by baggage reclaim and then quietly becomes the bag you use for the school run too, which tells you something about how overrated the fancy weekend holdall often is.
The thing nobody warns you about is what a travel bag looks wrong next to. A structured, boxy weekend bag with a soft, slouchy coat just looks like you're carrying someone else's luggage, and a big logo-heavy holdall next to anything remotely smart makes you look like you're auditioning for a budget airline advert. Canvas and leather combinations tend to sit well with almost anything because they read as worn in rather than new, whereas shiny nylon with lots of branding wants a deliberately casual outfit around it or it fights for attention. On fit, the mistake I kept making for years was buying on looks alone and only testing the straps in the shop, standing still, bag empty. Load it the way you actually would, with a washbag, shoes and a jumper shoved in, then check the handles don't dig in and that it sits comfortably on your shoulder or in the crook of your arm for longer than thirty seconds. A lot of bags that look generous turn out to have a main compartment the shape of a loaf of bread, so check the actual opening, not just the dimensions on the label. Weight empty matters more than people expect, because a bag that's already heavy before you've packed a single sock becomes a genuine problem on a platform with no lift.
Where it falls short is anywhere you need to move fast or look remotely put together without trying. It is not a bag for a work trip where you're going straight into a meeting, and it is not a bag for anything requiring you to run for a connection with it banging against your legs. The difference between a good one and a disappointing one usually comes down to the zips and the base. Cheap zips catch and eventually just stop meeting in the middle, and a thin, unlined base means the bag goes shapeless and grubby within a few trips. Proper canvas or a treated nylon, a reinforced base, and stitching that doesn't fray at the strap joins are the real tells, far more than how nice the hardware looks on the shelf.
Reach for it for anything longer than a couple of nights away, or whenever you need one bag to survive being thrown in a boot, a hold, and then a cupboard under the stairs for the next six months.