The single thing worth knowing before you buy a cardigan is that the weight of the yarn decides everything else about it, the drape, the warmth, how it survives being shoved in a bag when the heating comes on halfway through the afternoon. Get that wrong and nothing else about the cut will save it.
A good one has a bit of heft to the knit rather than a thin, see through stitch that pills the first time it meets a coat sleeve. Run your hand over it before you buy. You want the fabric to feel dense, not papery, and you want to check the ribbing at the cuffs and hem, because that's the part that gives up first, stretching out into two sad loops by the second wash if the knit is cheap. Buttons matter more than people give them credit for. Proper horn or a decent resin button with a shank sits flat and doesn't pull at the hole, whereas the flimsy flat ones tend to crack or go loose within a month, and then you're sewing a button back on in a corridor before a meeting, which is not a situation anyone needs. Seams at the shoulder and underarm should lie flat rather than rolling, and if you can see the join where sleeve meets body puckering even slightly on the hanger, it'll only get worse on your arm.
For fit, the main thing to watch is the shoulder seam, because a cardigan that's too big there will droop and make even a smart jumper underneath look borrowed. Length is personal but worth thinking about properly: a cardigan that stops right at the hip bone can add width exactly where you don't want it, while one that drops a few inches lower tends to skim and flatter almost everyone, which is the closest thing to a reliable rule I've found. If you're between sizes, go up rather than down, since a cardigan that's slightly roomy still works layered, but one that strains across the back or pulls at the buttons looks cheap however good the fabric actually is.
Where it struggles is obvious once you think about it. A cardigan isn't built for proper cold, a sharp January wind goes straight through most knits unless you're adding a coat over the top anyway, and it's not the thing to reach for if you need something that holds its shape all day without a bit of give, because by nature it moves and softens as you wear it.
Does it hang well with nothing underneath it, or is it only doing its job once you've added three more layers to make it behave?
Our Shortlist of Zip Cardigans
Knitted CardigansEasy Wool Knitted Cardigans for Everyday Wear
Shop the Edit: Wool Cardigans
The Prettiest White V Neck Cardigans Around Right Now
Knitted CardigansCosy White Knitted Cardigans We Love
White Cardigans That Go With Everything
Easy White Button Cardigans for Everyday Wear
The Only V Neck Cardigans You Need to See
Knitted CardigansV Neck Knitted Cardigans We RateAlso worth a lookKnitted CardigansThe thing that catches people out with knitted cardigans is the stretch.See the collections →
Tall Cardigans for Off Duty Days
The Striped Cardigans on Our Wishlist
Handpicked Short Sleeve Cardigans We Keep Coming Back To
Knitted CardigansRibbed Knitted Cardigans That Earn Their Place
The Ribbed Cardigans Shortlist
Ribbed Cropped Cardigans That Tick Every Box
Everyday Pink Cardigans We Love
Oversized Cardigans That Go With Everything
Our Edit of the Best Navy CardigansAlso worth a lookJumpersThis is the first thing I reach for once the heating goes back on properly and the light drops by half past four.See the collections →
Longline Cardigans Worth Layering
Easy Long Sleeve Cardigans for Everyday Wear
Lightweight Cardigans Worth Layering
Knitted CardigansKnitted Cardigans Worth Adding to Your Wardrobe
Grey Cardigans Worth Layering
Green Cardigans for Off Duty Days
Finding the Best Fluffy Cardigans
Knitted CardigansFine Knit Cardigans: The Ones Worth Your Money
Easy Cropped Cardigans for Everyday WearAlso worth a lookBeige JumpersA beige jumper is the one you reach for when you want to look put together without having actually planned anything.See the collections →
Knitted CardigansCropped Knitted Cardigans We Can’t Stop Looking At
Crew Neck Cardigans Worth a Closer Look
Knitted CardigansCotton Knitted Cardigans for Off Duty Days
The Cotton Cardigans We’re Eyeing Up This Season
Cotton Cropped Cardigans to Wear With Your Favourite Jeans
The Cosy Cardigans We Keep Going Back To
Knitted CardigansChunky Knit Cardigans: The Ones Worth Your Money
Knitted CardigansOur Kind of Casual Knitted Cardigans
