If you're stood there holding a black boot, the first thing I'd ask is where the zip sits and whether you can actually get it over your calf without lying on the bed to do it up. Black boots are the one bit of footwear almost everyone owns, but the fit round the ankle and calf is where most of mine have let me down over the years. A boot that gapes at the top looks sloppy under trousers and lets all the cold air in, and one that's too snug will cut a line across your leg by mid afternoon. Check you can bend your knee properly in the shop, not just stand there admiring them in the mirror, because that's the test that matters once you're walking rather than posing.
Black boots don't love being paired with anything too fussy underneath. Thick textured tights with a lot going on, or a hem that's a slightly warmer black, can look oddly mismatched once you're outside in daylight rather than under shop lighting. I'd also be careful mixing a very shiny patent boot with anything else shiny on the same outfit, it starts to look like you got dressed in a hurry near a disco ball. A matte or slightly textured finish is far easier to live with day to day, it goes with more and hides scuffs better than high shine, which shows every scrape within a fortnight of normal wear.
Mine age well if I actually look after them, which I don't always manage. A suede pair I wore through one whole fairly wet autumn went patchy at the toe because I never bothered with a protector spray before the first proper downpour, and by December they looked like they'd been dragged behind a car. Leather ones are more forgiving, a wipe down and a bit of polish every few weeks keeps them looking decent, and they soften and mould to your foot in a way that actually improves with wear rather than wrecking them. Stuff them with paper when they're wet rather than leaving them to dry near a radiator, that's the bit I always forget until the leather's gone stiff and cracked at the crease.
Where they're the wrong choice is anywhere genuinely smart in a formal, old fashioned sense, a black boot still reads as casual to some eyes no matter how polished, and they're no good for standing all day on hard flooring without proper cushioning, your feet will remind you by four o'clock. For most ordinary days, work, weekends, the school run, an evening out, they're the thing I reach for without even thinking about it.
Wide Fit BootsWide Fit Black Boots: The Edit
Wide Fit BootsOur Favourite Wide Fit Black Heeled Boots
Wide Fit BootsShop Our Favourite Wide Fit Black Knee High Boots
Wide Fit BootsWide Fit Black Platform Boots on Our Radar
Biker BootsWide Fit Black Biker Boots We’ve Been Saving
Ankle BootsThe Plus Size Black Ankle Boots on Our Wishlist
Ankle BootsPlus Size Black Ankle Boots: The Ones Worth Your Money
Plus Size Black Boots Picked by Us
Knee High BootsThe Plus Size Black Knee High Boots on Our WishlistAlso worth a lookAnkle BootsIf you're trying one on and it already pinches across the top of the foot while you're stood still, put it back.See the collections →
Wide Fit BootsThe Only Extra Wide Fit Black Ankle Boots You Need to See
Wide Fit BootsShop Our Favourite Extra Wide Fit Black Ankle Boots
Biker BootsExtra Wide Fit Black Biker Boots Made for Walking
Wide Fit BootsExtra Wide Fit Black Boots That Tick Every Box
Wide Fit BootsExtra Wide Fit Black Knee High Boots That Have Caught Our Eye
Wide Fit BootsExtra Wide Fit Black Lace Up Boots That Have Caught Our Eye
Wide Fit BootsThe Extra Wide Fit Black Sock Boots Worth Your Wardrobe Space
Wide Fit BootsThe Extra Wide Fit Black Walking Boots Worth Investing In
Sock BootsThe Black Zip Sock Boots on Our WishlistAlso worth a lookBrown BootsBrown boots do a different job to black ones, whatever the shop assistant tells you when you're stood there with two pairs and no clue.See the collections →
Walking BootsBlack Zip Walking Boots: Our Honest Shortlist
Western BootsBlack Zip Western Boots on Our Radar
Ankle BootsThe Best Black Zip Ankle Boots to Shop Now
Ankle BootsBlack Zip Ankle Boots That Make Any Outfit
Biker BootsOur Shortlist of Black Zip Biker Boots
Black Zip Boots Made for Walking
Chelsea BootsHandpicked Black Zip Chelsea Boots We Keep Coming Back To
The Best Black Zip Cowboy Boots to Shop Now
Heeled BootsBlack Zip Heeled Boots That Make Any OutfitAlso worth a lookLace Up BootsLace up boots have the reputation of being the boot that never really goes out of fashion, the…See the collections →
Knee High BootsBlack Zip Knee High Boots We Think You’ll Love
Lace Up BootsBlack Zip Lace Up Boots Picked by Us
Over the Knee BootsOur Pick of the Best Black Zip Over the Knee Boots
Platform BootsBlack Zip Platform Boots Worth a Closer Look
Black Zip Snow Boots That Earn Their Place
Knee High BootsThe Best Black Woven Knee High Boots to Shop Now
Lace Up BootsOur Top Black Woven Lace Up Boots Right Now
Over the Knee BootsBlack Woven Over the Knee Boots Worth Adding to Your Wardrobe
